Discussion: Songs You Don’t Like By Artists You Do

I did a post similar to this last November (“Songs I Hate by Artists I Love”) but readership has grown exponentially since then, and the topic complements yesterday’s perfectly. Since I already hit up the Dixie Chicks, Alan Jackson, Dolly Parton, Pam Tillis and Dwight Yoakam back then, I’ll turn my sights on another act that I rarely find fault with: Trisha Yearwood.

There are only two Trisha Yearwood albums that I don’t particularly care for. The first is her debut, Trisha Yearwood, which features four great singles and another track or two that I somewhat enjoy. As a whole, though, it’s a tentative affair, which is understandable, given that it’s a debut album and all.

The other is less excusable. Released at the height of her popularity, Where Your Road Leads was her only album to feature Tony Brown at the helm. I could forgive its pop flavor if it was actually good pop, but never before or since has Yearwood been paired with such forgettable material. For me, the worst offender was one of the hits: “Powerful Thing.”

I’ve never understood the appeal of this song. It’s a few beats too slow, and there’s no discernible melody in the verses, which are sung like they’re supposed to rhyme, even though they don’t. Then there’s the chorus, with its repeated declarations of “it’s a powerful thing”, a maddeningly vague description that the rest of the lyrics fail to illuminate. It’s radio-friendly pap that’s beneath the singer trying to sell it, the worst offender on the album that is thankfully both Yearwood’s first and last blatant attempt at making a commercial record.

What are some songs you don’t like by artists you do?

Be Sociable, Share!

30 Comments

Filed under Discussion, Open Thread

30 Responses to Discussion: Songs You Don’t Like By Artists You Do

  1. MarcNo Gravatar

    Keeping it to hits/singles that are easily recognizable…
    Trisha Yearwood – Heaven, Heartache and the Power of Love
    Dixie Chicks – Goodbye Earl
    Tim McGraw – Indian Outlaw

  2. Let’s see here (I’m going through my Itunes library.
    Adam Gregory – “Don’t Send The Invitation”
    Alan Jackson – “Chasin’ That Neon Rainbow”
    Billy Currington – “Tangled Up”
    Blake Shelton – “She Wouldn’t Be Gone”
    Brad Paisley – “I’m Still A Guy”
    Brooks & Dunn – “Proud Of The House We Built”
    Buddy Jewell – “This Ain’t Mexico”
    Craig Morgan – “Love Remembers”

    and Yeah I’m too lazy to go through the rest, maybe I’ll do it later

  3. ZachNo Gravatar

    Kenny Chesney- Shiftwork
    Trisha Yearwood- Powerful Thing
    Faith Hill- Let Me let go (ehh.)
    Sugarland- All I Want To Do (I never rlly liked the song much)
    Alan Jackson- A Woman’s Love (blah.)
    no more I can think of….

    I am half and half on Hill, Sugarland, and Yearwood’s songs.. Now I hate them.. tmw who knows? LOL

  4. Where Your Road Leads is the only one of Yearwood’s albums that I’ve ever sold off. “Powerful Thing” is a mess for all of the reasons you detailed, but I slightly prefer it to the Dianne Warren nightmare of “I’ll Still Love You More,” every second of which is just wretched stuff. I also don’t like “How Do I Live,” but I don’t think it sounds like Trisha phoned in the vocal on that one, as is the case on the other Warren song in her repertoire. Still, it takes a vocalist of her caliber to make any of Warren’s greeting card goo even slightly resemble actual human emotion.

    I’m not a fan of “I Try to Think About Elvis” by Patty Loveless. She sings it well because she’s Patty Loveless and she does that, but there’s no hiding that it’s a throwaway novelty song.

  5. ZachNo Gravatar

    I second Jordan’s “I’m Still A guy”

  6. Chris D.No Gravatar

    I third “I’m Still A Guy”, it’s way too sexist.

    Another is “Valentine” by Martina McBride. It’s one of the only songs by her that I don’t like. I just don’t like it for some reason.

  7. Blake BoldtNo Gravatar

    Thankfully Trisha Yearwood recaptured the magic with Real Live Woman.

    I think “I Try to Think About Elvis”, although not a member of my Top 25 Patty Loveless list, is just enough tongue-in-cheek to work, IMO, but I understand how one could possibly dislike it.

    I would select “Don’t Take the Girl” by Tim McGraw. An overwrought, three-act story that has aged in production. Tim has done much deeper, stronger material since.

  8. MarcNo Gravatar

    Zach: wow.. let me let go is one of my favorite Hill songs… secret of life and breathe on the other hand… :)

  9. Erik NorthNo Gravatar

    As much as I make of the fact that I like the vast majority of what Linda Ronstadt does, I am not enamored of “High Sierra”, either in the mix done for TRIO 2 with Dolly and Emmylou, or on her 1995 solo album FEELS LIKE HOME. And incredibly it’s not the song’s lyrics that bother me; it is Linda’s overly mannered attempt at sounding high and lonesome. She nailed this sort of thing in the early 1970s without any trouble, but she doesn’t do it as well on this song.

  10. pselbyNo Gravatar

    Sticking to recent stuff —
    Sugarland – Everyday America
    Brad Paisley – Online
    George Strait – I Saw God Today
    Alan Jackson – Southern Man (or whatever it’s called)
    Cross Canadian Ragweed – Cry Lonely

    This goes back a few years, but Dolly Parton’s version of “Stairway To Heaven” was horrible.

  11. Paul W DennisNo Gravatar

    Dolly Parton “Great Balls of Fire”
    Dolly Parton “Old Flames”
    Martina McBride “Valentine”

    Linda Ronstadt “Blue Bayou” (there should be a law against tackling Orbison songs – only Orbison and perhaps Narvel Felts and Don MacLean should be allowed to do so

    George Strait “The Fireman”

    Reba “Fancy” & “Cathy’s Clown”

    Also, virtually any Diane Warren song, no matter who sings it

  12. stephanieNo Gravatar

    Tim McGraw- Last Dollar and Kristofferson. Poor singles from an album that has better songs (I’m working, Shotgun rider)

  13. RainbowNo Gravatar

    “Bringing Out The Elvis” by Faith Hill. I love Faith, but that’s truly one of the worst songs I’ve ever heard.
    “Forever Love” by Reba. I think it’s an OK song, but Reba’s voice isn’t suited for it. I’d like to hear Martina McBride or Trisha sing it.

  14. KathyPNo Gravatar

    Toby Keith – “she’s a hottie”

  15. ScottNo Gravatar

    “Where i come From”, When Somebody Loves you”, and “Red on a Rose” Alan Jackson
    King of the mountain and “We REally Shouldnt be doing This” by George Strait
    Last Name–Carrie Underwood
    When the Stars Go Blue” by Tim McGraw

    Again just a short list..i could name a lot more

  16. lcbNo Gravatar

    Martina McBride….”When God-Fearin’ Women, etc.”
    Alan Jackson….”Good Time”
    Faith Hill….”Mississippi Girl”
    Brad Paisley….”Ticks”

  17. Casey

    I own every single George Strait album, but the one song from this massive collection that I don’t have on my iPod is “Looking Out My Window Through The Pain” from his self-titled George Strait album. I get the whole emotional pain/window pane double entendre bit, but this song just falls very flat for me. In contrast, from the same album we have “Which Side of the Glass,” which has a sort of triple entendre (if there is such a thing) with the window glass/drinking glass/mirrow glass. That’s a much better song and a much better use of entendre…am I using that word right?

    But, at the end of the day, I still love King George. :)

  18. bobby

    i didn’t get it at the time, but i went back and got keith urban’s self titled cd and i thought it was mediocre at best.

  19. Kim

    Last Name-Carrie
    Honky Tonk Bandonak, Swing-Trace Adkins
    Tim McGraw, Picture To Burn-Taylor Swift
    There You Are, Valentine-Martina
    Bringing Out The Elvis-Faith Hill
    Biker Chick-Jo Dee Messina
    Dancin For The Groceries-Kenny Chesney
    Why Why Why-Billy Currington
    Red High Heels-Kellie Pickler

  20. George Strait’s duet With Kenny – Shift Work
    I love George but that’s a dud.

    Alan Jackson – http://www.memory
    Reba – Fancy

    Gary Allan – Tough Little Boys
    I constantly try to get some music snob alt-country buddies of mine to get into Gary, but this song shot my credibility all to hell.

  21. Kim

    thought of some more..

    Skoal Ring, Come To Bed-Gretchen Wilson
    I Got My Game On-Trace Adkins
    Squeezin The Love Outta You, Head Over Heels-Caroyln Dawn Johsnon
    Chicks Dig It-Chris Cagle

  22. Brooks and Dunn “Boot Scootin’ Boogie”

  23. JaneNo Gravatar

    Martina McBride – I always disliked “City of Love” and “Learning to Fall” from the Martina album, both of them are just plain not very good.

    Sara Evans – The song “Cupid” from No Place That Far kind of grates on my nerves. And I never liked “Big Cry” from Restless (The rest of the album is awesome though).

    Carrie Underwood – Inside your heaven, and Twisted.

  24. LindaNo Gravatar

    “Sin Wagon” – Dixie Chicks
    “Born to Fly” – Sara Evans

    I used to like LeAnn Rimes and I thought her entire album “Sittin’ On Top of the World” was horrible, with her version of “Purple Rain” being the worst.

  25. HelenNo Gravatar

    Hole In My Head: Dixie Chicks (I really love their music but I can’t stand that song)
    I’ll Take You Back: Brad Paisley
    All I Want To Do: Sugarland
    Twisted: Carrie Underwood
    Gunpowder and Lead: Miranda Lambert

  26. GailNo Gravatar

    Last Dollar – Tim McGraw…I love Tim, but will turn the radio off when this song comes on!

    Same with George Strait and KC with Shiftwork! YUK!

    Gunpowder & Lead – Miranda Lambert…so sick of this song.

    That Train’s acomin song by Dierks Bentley!
    There is so many more but can’t think right now!

  27. PeterNo Gravatar

    I’m one of the biggest Sara Evans fans around but could not stomach Backseat Of A Greyhound Bus

  28. KimNo Gravatar

    I agree about Where Your Road Leads. I’m a huge fan of Trisha, but that album was a dud. My least favorite Trisha song though is XXX’s and OOO’s. I could never stand that song.

    Vince Gill – Liza Jane

    Martina McBride – My Baby Loves Me

    Diamond Rio – Bubba Hyde

  29. ZachNo Gravatar

    I also agree with McBride’s “Valentine”

    well Marc, “Breathe” and “Secret Of Life” happen to be among my fav Hill songs LOL :)

  30. LynnNo Gravatar

    I’ll third “Gunpowder and Lead” from Miranda Lambert. And add “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend”.

    (btw….if you think those two songs sum up Miranda, you NEED to give her another listen! ;)