March 16, 2012
1999 | #13
“You’ve Got a Way” is a beautiful showcase of the unique set of gifts Shania Twain brought to the table as a vocalist.
Her detractors often maligned her vocal abilities, dismissing her as a subpar talent, as she did lack the range and power possessed by several of her contemporaries (such as Faith Hill, Martina McBride, and Trisha Yearwood). Many failed to appreciate the fact that Twain had a strong talent for exuding sincerity in her performances, whichs adds more to a song’s impact than even the highest power notes.
Though having just conquered the world with a succession of hook-heavy pop crossover hits, Twain abruptly changed the rules with “You’ve Got a Way,” instead unplugging with a soft acoustic ballad. Twain does all of the heavy lifting with her vocal delivery, and does so beautifully – with restraint, and a bit of an emotional quiver. It’s a perfect fit for a lyric that is a simple, straightforward expression of love and appreciation.
I would recommend steering clear of the gaudy pop remix used in the film Notting Hill, as it interrupts the flow of emotion with unnecessary echo effects, an intrusive beat, and other distractions. The original country version, however, ranks among Twain’s best work.
Written by Shania Twain and Robert John “Mutt” Lange
Grade: A (country version); B- (remix)
Previous: Man! I Feel Like a Woman!
Next: Come On Over
Original country version:
Notting Hill mix: