100 Greatest Men: #1. Merle Haggard

Merle Haggard100 Greatest Men: The Complete List

The Poet of the Common Man.  Merle Haggard emerged from the Bakersfield music scene in the mid-sixties, and over the course of time, became the greatest man in the history of country music.

Born during the height of the Great Depression, the son of a honky tonk fiddler and a church-going mother, Haggard’s life was a hard one from early on.  When he lost his father at age nine, he rebelled to the point that much of his youth was spent in juvenile detention centers.  His only positive outlet was country music, and he listened to and studied obsessively the work of his heroes Bob Willis, Hank Williams, and Lefty Frizzell, all of whom would shape his singing and his songwriting.

Haggard entered a tortured period, where he was quickly developing into a musical talent but also becoming quite the petty criminal.  Haggard spent most of his teens and early twenties in and out of detention centers and prisons.  During one time on the outside, he attended a Lefty Frizzell concert and found his way backstage.  After singing for Frizzell, Haggard’s hero refused to go onstage until Haggard got to sing for the audience first, and Haggard received a thunderous ovation.

This encouragement was not enough to keep him from his criminal life, and after he attempted to break in to a restaurant he thought was closed – it wasn’t – Haggard was arrested and sentenced to fifteen years in San Quentin Prison.   He continued to cause problems while in jail, but eventually was turned around by the counseling of a death row prisoner that he didn’t want to permanently join in that part of the prison. So he took classes and played in the prison band, and was finally released in 1960, ready to pursue his musical career.

Manual labor by day, music by night was the routine for Haggard in Bakersfield, California, until his popularity in the local club scene allowed for him to quit his day job.   Soon, Buck Owens was making the Bakersfield Sound a national sensation, and after playing in Wynn Stewart’s badn  for a spell, Haggard struck out on his own, landing a recording contract with Tally Records.

When his Tally releases caught national attention, Capitol bought out his record contract.  Success then came rapidly for Haggard.  From 1966 on, Haggard released commercially successful and critically acclaimed albums and singles that established him as the voice for the common man.  Singing about his own experiences in prison and in poverty, Haggard’s skill as a songwriter, coupled with his highly stylized vocals, resonated deeply with a listening audience that sensed the pure pathos and open empathy Haggard had for their lot in life.

He was the prisoner who couldn’t shake his criminal past in “Branded Man.”  He was the factory worker trapped in a job that was slowly working him to death in “Working Man’s Blues.”  He was the steadfast country boy refusing to change who he is despite the rapid changes in society all around him in “Okie From Muskogee.”   He was the proud patriot defending his country and his flag in “The Fightin’ Side of Me.”

He was the son who let his mama down in “Mama Tried”, and the son who  just remembered how his dad could never work hard enough to give her what she deserved in “Hungry Eyes.”  He was he man who was drinking to  escape a memory but it was wasn’t working in “Bottle Let Me Down.”  He was the man who decided to keep drinking anyway in “I Think I’ll Just Stay Here and Drink.”   He was the country boy lost in the urban jungle in “Big City.”  He was the laid-off dad who couldn’t afford to play Santa to his little girl in “If We Make it Through December.”

He was one of them.  He was all of them.  He was every man who worked hard, played by the rules, and still couldn’t get ahead.  He was every man who ever felt misunderstood, left behind, or just plain invisible.  He gave them all a voice by telling their story, and for two or three minutes at a time, restored some of the dignity that the world had slowly chipped away, one grinding day at a time.

All of these qualities made him a huge success, of course.  The kind of legend that this list is all about.  There were dozens of #1 hits, millions of records sold, countless industry awards, and even after radio moved on, as it always does, a consistent stream of solid albums with great songs written by him and sung just as well as the old ones were when he was on the top of the charts. Of course he’s in the Hall of Fame.  Has been since 1994.

But what makes him the greatest man in the history of country music isn’t just his peerless singing, poetic songwriting, and guitar-playing prowess, though all of that is certainly essential to the end result.  It isn’t even just the voice he gave to the ignored, the downtrodden, and the hard-working men (and women) who never get the glory they deserve.

He’s the greatest because he is the quintessential country artist.  Merle Haggard is the common thread that links together the best of what came before him, and he’s been the biggest influence on all of the best that came after him.  That’s Haggard in that Randy Travis vocal.  That’s Haggard in that plainspoken and real Alan Jackson song,  That’s Haggard in that Brad Paisley guitar lick.

There have been many great men in the history of country music.  We wrote about one hundred of them over the past three years.  But none of them wrote as many great songs, made as many great albums, sang as many great melodies, or played as many great guitar licks as Merle Haggard.  There might be some who did one or two things better than he did, but nobody has been as consistently great in as many ways as Merle Haggard has been.  He took the best lessons from all of his heroes, and in turn, passed them on to the next generations of country singers who called him Hero.

Merle Haggard is the greatest.

Essential Singles:

  • The Bottle Let Me Down, 1966
  • Sing Me Back Home, 1967
  • Mama Tried, 1968
  • Workin’ Man Blues, 1969
  • Okie From Muskogee, 1969
  • The Fightin’ Side of Me, 1970
  • Carolyn, 1971
  • If we Make it Through December, 1973
  • I Think I’ll Just Stay Here and Drink, 1980
  • Big City, 1982
  • Are the Good Times Really Over, 1982
  • Pancho and Lefty (with Willie Nelson), 1983
  • That’s the Way Love Goes, 1983

Essential Albums:

  • Swinging Doors and the Bottle Let Me Down, 1966
  • Sing Me Back Home, 1968
  • Mama Tried, 1968
  • Same Train, a Different Time, 1969
  • A Tribute to the Best Damn Fiddle Player in the World (or, My Salute to Bob Wills), 1970
  • Someday We’ll Look Back, 1971
  • Hag, 1971
  • Back to the Barrooms, 1980
  • Big City, 1981
  • Going Where the Lonely Go, 1982
  • 1996, 1996
  • Roots Vol. 1, 2001
  • The Bluegrass Sessions, 2007

Previous: #2. George Jones

100 Greatest Men: The Complete List

Be Sociable, Share!

13 Comments

Filed under 100 Greatest Men

13 Responses to 100 Greatest Men: #1. Merle Haggard

  1. Paul W DennisNo Gravatar

    Absolutely !

    Whereas Rodgers and Williams were more influential historical figures and Pierce and Tubb are quirky stylistic favorites of mine, I’ve always regarded Haggard as the best, from the time I purchased my first Haggard 45 in 1968 (“Ballad of Bonnie and Clyde”) through to the present day.

    In fact I marveled that the B-side of that first single I purchased could possibly be a song as strong as “Today I Started Loving Your Again”

    Every Haggard album is filled with treasures that never made the radio, and most of the Haggard singles had very strong B-sides. Kevin’s list of essential singles doesn’t include my two favorite singles and that’s okay – they’re all essential and you can’t have a list that long

  2. bobNo Gravatar

    I guess that Suzy Bogguss would approve of this selection.

  3. andythedrifterNo Gravatar

    Great selection for #1. When it comes to the total package – vocal ability, songwriting skills, influence, size and strength of discography – Merle is simply the all-around greatest man in country music.

  4. Erik NorthNo Gravatar

    I think the “Hag”‘s placement at the top of this list is very appropriate, considering how crowded the Top Ten is with mega-legends.

    I would say that, though “Okie From Muskogee” and “The Fightin’ Side Of Me” are among his two most prominent songs, especially in the context of the era that gave birth to them, the era of the Vietnam War, I think the notion that he aligned himself so staunchly with the American Right because of them is overrated, considering that a number of “hippie” acts with C&W influences have covered his classic material quite respectfully, including the Grateful Dead (“Mama Tried”), and Linda Ronstadt (“Silver Wings”, which she did on an Earl Scruggs album in 1971) (Merle had said that Linda was the best female singer he had ever heard). He is his own man, a true individual, one-of-a-kind–something that, I’m sorry to say, we just aren’t seeing any of today in country music.

  5. Pingback: Quotable Country – 08/17/14 Edition | Country California

  6. ThomasNo Gravatar

    Gotta say, I don’t think “Okie” was Haggard aligning himself with the American Right so much as parodying it.

  7. the pistoleroNo Gravatar

    I don’t think “Okie” was Haggard aligning himself with the American Right so much as parodying it.

    Yup. Hag later said that Muskogee was about the only place he didn’t toke up.

    But yes, Merle Haggard is indeed the greatest. There are simply none better.

  8. Merle Haggard is absolutely the perfect person to put at the top of this list. He fully embodies country music and what people should think of when they think of country music.

  9. SunsetParkNo Gravatar

    Great choice, and your description is spot on. With regard to the American Right and Okie…I don’t think the “American Right” was as clearly defined, and so clearly a seprate entity from country living, at the point those came out. Country boy and patriot – there are probably core definitions for each that he could still agree with. There are also current interpretations of each that he couldn’t likely stand to be aligned with.
    I saw him in concert several years back, and someone in the crowd shouted a song request out. Haggard responded that he made his own song choices at this point in his career. He has certainly earned that right. Your song list is great; but I’ve always been partial to Silver Wings.

  10. I should also add that this is an awesome and compelling article!

  11. Motown MikeNo Gravatar

    Real quick some of my favorite Haggard songs include . . .
    -Mama Tried
    -Okie From Muskogee
    -Kentucky Gambler
    -Branded Man
    -The Fightin’ Side of Me
    -Hobo Bill
    -Daddy Frank (The Guitar Man)
    -Yesterday’s Wine with Willie Nelson
    -I Threw Away the Rose
    -Kern River
    -They’re Tearin the Labor Camps Down
    -Big City
    -It’s All in the Movies

    Merle Haggard is the essence of an all-American storyteller, in any genre. He knows that a song is supposed to represent more than bodily movements and lyrical hums. His music is true art because it crafts characters, events, dates + times, and paints it all into a believable, emotional picture. When you listen to a Haggard song his struggle becomes your struggle. You place yourself in the middle of the song, becoming one of his characters and experiencing the depth first hand. His vocal ability is as strong as his writing. He’s not the best pure singer along the lines of a George Jones or a Alan Jackson. But he knows what it takes to deliver raw emotion into a song. He knows how to flesh out the characters he writes about as much through voice as he does with a pen and paper.

    His influence has crossed many genres and many decades. He’s even managed to shape artists around him like Willie, Waylon, Johnny George, Alan and on. Without him, country may not have had a true outlaw movement. Without him, many topics in song would go unwritten and many a persons story untold. Even modern, true country-roots artists, like Jason Isbell, Jason Eady, Kacey Musgraves, Holly Williams and Sturgill Simpson can clearly trace their style, choice of music and roots back to the Hag. Without Merle there would likely be no “Southeastern” by Jason Isbell, “Same Trailer, Different Park” by Kacey Musgraves or “The Highway” by Holly Williams. His legacy will live well beyond the walls of his music as it has transformed directly the music of so many others.

    If there were a list of greatest artists in modern, post 1920’s music, Haggard would be deserving of a top 10 placement amongst the company of Frank Sinatra. His talent have been and still are that immense and generational. His placement at #1 is the only place you could put him.

    This is the right conclusion to a great list of country artists. A fantastic job to Bevin, Dan, Leeann, Ben, Jonathan, Sam and anyone who even contributed a microcosm of information to this list. It has been a fantastic read. Thank you for all the work that was put into this!!!

  12. Kevin John CoyneNo Gravatar

    Was on the road for the past week and couldn’t check in after completing the list.

    All I have to say right now is that having Paul Dennis agree with the #1 choice is the best endorsement for this list that I could’ve gotten, and made the work worthwhile!

  13. Tom PNo Gravatar

    I have to admit I thought you would have chosen George Jones or Hank Sr, or J. Cash, but after reading your thoughts I have to agree Merle is a great choice. When you look at his length, iconic hits, and add the songwriting to that it does make perfect sense. Great list overall!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This site is using OpenAvatar based on