The journalist noted his surprise at the title track, which demonstrated more subtlety and gravitas than he’d previously thought McGraw was capable of.
That was so many years ago that it’s hard to remember that McGraw was something of a novelty singer back in the day, a step or two above Billy Ray Cyrus but not quite up there with Joe Diffie.
Fourteen years later, we’ve had so many thoughtful and compelling records from McGraw that when a new one comes along, it’s easy to take it for granted. Standing in the shadow of “Live Like You Were Dying” is a hard place to shine.
So while “Better Than it Used to Be” is classic McGraw and a welcome relief to hear after “Felt Good on My Lips”, it’s not quite in the league of his very best songs in the same vein, like “One of These Days” and “My Next Thirty Years.”
But I do have to publicly thank him for the clean, tasteful, and decidedly country production. Any record that doesn’t hurt my ears these days is greatly appreciated.
Written by Ashley Gorey and Brian Simpson
Listen: Better Than I Used to Be