Album Review Roundup: Vol. 2, No. 34

Wynonna’s revelatory masterpiece leads the week.

 

Wynonna

The Hard Truth

She’s spent her entire career to date– which is to say, the majority of her life– surrounded by people who were more interested in what her formidable skills could do for them than in how they could help her live as and express her authentic self. As she sings early on here, “They threw me in to see if I could swim / Didn’t gave a hand to reach out and grab.” That she could and did swim or, in her own words, tap-dance, was a function of her own gifts.

And while she has rightfully claimed space as an all-time great and a CMHoF member, there’s remained that tension in her catalogue of (canon-ready, yes) work, that her voice was being stifled by the expectations others– her mother, most critically, but also people like Mike Curb– had for who she was supposed to be and what she was supposed to say.

It’s telling that to this point in her solo career, she’s credited as co-writer on just three total album tracks, the same number of credits Naomi has.

The Hard Truth, then, is the album on which Wynonna reclaims her time and, with absolute clarity and moral conviction, her voice.

She co-wrote 10 of these 11 songs, and they are, to a one, spectacular and unflinching in their honesty and in her desire to speak her truth to power. It recalls Trisha Yearwood’s 2025 masterpiece The Mirror for how a generational song interpreter has suddenly announced herself as a songwriter.

It’s no coincidence that she’s now surrounded by collaborators– primarily her husband, who serves as her drummer, co-writer, producer, and loudest champion– who understand her talents and want to support her in realizing her vision. Iron & Wine (!), Patterson Hood (!), and The War & Treaty (!) are the caliber of friends and collaborators she is able to command here, a perfect indication of how the album encapsulates her mainstream country, rock, soul, and Americana influences in a way that sounds how a Wynonna album always should’ve sounded.

Still, it’s the perspective reflected in the writing that makes the album a career landmark and among the strongest country records of this or any recent year. She pulls first-person details about what it took to climb out of generational poverty and the generational traumas that resulted from that journey. To say that her relationship with her mother is a complicated one would undersell the stories Wynonna chooses to share in these songs, while “Girl Who Could Sing,” which she sings directly to the late father she never knew, is as vulnerable a song as I can recall hearing from an artist of her stature.

Through all of it, she finds genuine pride in her KY roots– she is firmly laying claim to her spot in the KY music renaissance of Childers, Goodman, Taylor, Noe, and so many others– and the strength to extend sincere grace and compassion, even to those who’ve harmed her.

Hers is a journey of growing up under an uncommon degree of scrutiny and in a family whose difficulties played out in public. The Hard Truth is, at times, a hard listen, especially for those of us with complex family dynamics, but it’s worth it to, at long last, hear Wynonna’s absolute truth.

 


Sad Daddy

Ozark Shine

They’re a talented lot in terms of musicianship and songcraft, but the schtick too often skews condescending to the source material, like an old-timey stringband version of Southern Culture on the Skids if SCotS weren’t actually in on the jokes. Hoping I just misread.

 

Lawrence Rothman

Here Lies Love ~ Sawdust to Stardust

One of the most gifted singers in the modern country / Americana space, Rothman digs deeper than ever on their fifth and finest album. This is a difficult listen, as Rothman reckons with how experiences of grief, addiction and recovery, and heartbreak have shaped and continue to shape their identity in ways that require very real emotional labor to navigate.

Rothman’s wise enough to recognize that the sawdust left behind is the permanent product that proves that they’ve put in the work. The album impresses for their refusal to romanticize any of this.

 

The Shires

Bonfire

Two exceptionally lovely voices arranged in thoughtful and intricate harmonies, singing banal, cliché-ridden lyrics over slick pop-country production so dull it would lull Lady [Redacted] to sleep. Pretty, vapid.

 

Miranda Lambert

Crisco

During her peerless regal era, her albums were comprised of songs that reflected both a POV and caliber of songcraft that were singularly and identifiably hers. She may be too talented to deliver a truly bad album– this isn’t– but, don’t look now, it’s been a full decade since her last great solo record.

The production, drawing specific references from 70s pop-country that are sure to be dismissed as “slop” by those incurious about the source material because it’s genre-specific, is a pivot that suits her quite well. And she remains a singer of distinct and thoughtful phrasing.

But these songs– but for “Cuttin’ Onions,” which is of a piece with prior songs of hers which focus on a singular object or task– could have been written by or for anyone in the current country space, not by or for the finest artist of her generation.

 

Kenny Chesney

Silver Sands Marina

His limited technical skill and inconsistent taste in material and collaborators– Lily Meola’s here, but so is Moroney– means this is right at his ceiling. Per usual, the best tracks lean into the cragginess of his aged voice and look beyond his beachcomber persona.

 

Conrad Fisher

Songs I Sing All Night

Fisher has long been a craftsman in every sense of the term, but there is both a mastery and purity to his work on this collection that reflects a refinement of his considerable skills. The album is just Fisher, his guitar, and his uncommonly lovely singing voice.

The album’s minimalism keeps the focus on Fisher’s songs and his command of familiar, simple melodies and traditional folk and country structures. But it’s the empathy in his POV– there’s a song here that recasts the birth of Christ in the context of current US immigration policy– that transcends.

As albums in this vein go, this scans as more conventional and traditionally country than, say, Patty Griffin’s canon-worthy Living With Ghosts. But it’s of a piece with that album in the sense that it’s the kind of thing other artists would mine for songs to cover, while it’s plenty moving as-is.

 

Joy Oladokun

Hope is a Heavy Thing

Burnt out from her time in the Americana space, one of the most empathetic songwriters of her generation looks to the past to find sources of inspiration for a better way forward. The adult-pop arrangements skew a bit anodyne, but her writing and singing remain vital.

 


Bobby Dove

Fortune Teller

A prime example of how traditional country forms can still be used to tell contemporary stories, this record stands as a leveling-up for Dove in terms of their command of narrative and genre. A couple of extra takes to iron out some pitchiness would have been welcome, sure, but it’s Dove’s chickenwire-sharp wit (“Trans Canadian Blues” as a wordplay took me the entire way out) that makes this project essential.

Dove’s identity-forward songwriting centers queer, trans lives in trad-country idioms, and their POV and work are much needed in 2026.

7 Comments

  1. The Bobby dove album has been one of my favorites this year glad to see it covered here! Not much of an outlaw is the first song on my best of 2026 playlist

  2. I hesitate to bring it up and feel free to delete if you want to keep politics out of this, but, due to her support of MAGA, I’m struggling to muster up any excitement for this new Wynonna album, no matter how great this review is or how much I have been a fan in the past. I feel like this issue came up a year or so ago with another artist and I can’t remember if you ever did a follow-up post on artists and politics, but I’m curious to hear from others on this one. I used to think I could overlook those things if the art was strong enough (never an issue with someone like, say, Jason Aldean), but the offenses of this regime have been so egregious (in my view), that I can’t, in good conscience, fork over money to someone who supports it. Anyway, curious to hear your thoughts and, again, feel free to delete if you feel it’s inappropriate to bring politics into this. Thanks!

    • Also not trying to get too political here, but I too was a little hesitant about the new Wynonna record, especially as her alleged MAGA status has been brought up again recently (she’s since gone on record saying she’s never discussed politics with Rosie O’Donnell and that she’s an Independent). I brought up reconciling artists you typically support with their political beliefs about a year or so ago, and Jonathan published an outstanding piece on the topic here on the site (It’s entitled A Separate Peace and you can also find it on CU’s Bluesky account). So yeah, on the fence with that one and Lambert’s new one as well (which I’ve heard some of and like the vibe and aesthetic, but..).

      • Chris beat me to it on linking to the “A Separate Peace” essay, which I will say is still an accurate reflection of my thoughts on this topic. Which, no, is definitely not off-limits for discussion here because, despite some claims to the contrary, we welcome difficult and challenging discussion about all things country music, so long as the discussants abide by our comment policy!

        My take on Wy, specifically, is that she would not have clarified her own status as a political independent if she did not believe that the characterization– by her friend, Rosie O’Donnell– of her as MAGA was *inaccurate*. This is someone who is nothing if not media savvy, and she understands the calculus around making an overt political statement. She’s very much in her “honest” era now that she has the freedom to be, and she’d have left the topic alone if she felt that she’d been described accurately.

        Like I said in the essay, it’s not about demanding ideological purity, and I’m sure there are some matters of politics and faith where Wynonna and I diverge. But I don’t see her as someone who is actively engaging in the perpetuation of harms or divisiveness I described.

        Y’know, as opposed to someone like Lee Brice, whose new album I won’t be listening to or reviewing.

        • Thanks for weighing in, guys, and reminding me of the name of that post! I was initially side-eying Wy’s statement on her politically independent stance with some skepticism as I thought she was just walking back her support now that MAGA’s popularity is decreasing, but I am going to choose to take her at her word. Honestly, I wouldn’t even mind if she had come out and said, “You know what? I supported him, but I can see now that I was wrong.” Hard as it may be for those of us who weren’t fooled to resist the “I told you sos”, I’m trying to exercise more compassion and forgiveness. Thanks again!

  3. I agree that Wynonn’as album is a masterpiece. It’s hard to hear such deep pain from someone whose music has brought so much fun and joy to my life, but it’s also cathartic and necessary. I heard in an interview that this album has been ten years in the making and when she was asked if she would’ve released so much of the truth on it if Naomi was still alive, she honestly answered that she didn’t know. That seemed like a fair answer to me.

    As for her politics, it’s hard to reconcile that she thinks as she does, but I also have a father whom I love and I know is a deeply compassionate person whose politics I also don’t understand or agree with. So, I’ve chosen to go the way of her collaborators on this album. It seems that The War and Treaty and Patterson Hood are not MAGA supporters. I know this is not the best or most reliable way to decide if one can support an artist whose politics make me cringe and disappoint me, but it does help me a little. As I’ve said before, if I had to agree with all of the music artists that I liked, I would not be able to support most country artists, including many of my favorite nineties artists. So, I’m disappointed, but begrudgingly used to it. On the other hand, I’m always so happy when I find that an artist that I love or like has political and social beliefs that align with mine.

    I reflixively purchase Miranda Lambert albums, but I haven’t bought this one yet. The seventies production isn’t my favorite in general, but I will likely end up buying it in the end.

    • I would *strongly* recommend streaming the Miranda record before investing, in that case! It is really only about the 70s vibe, so if that isn’t doin’ it for you…

      But I also thought for a long time that I’d be a Lambert completist, so I do understand the impulse!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*