Single Review: Tim McGraw, “Better Than I Used to Be”

Flipping through an old country magazine, I read a review of Tim McGraw’s then-new album, Everywhere.

The journalist noted his surprise at the title track, which demonstrated more subtlety and gravitas than he’d previously  thought McGraw was capable of.

That was so many years ago that it’s hard to remember that McGraw was something of a novelty singer back in the day, a step or two above Billy Ray Cyrus but not quite up there with Joe Diffie.

Fourteen years later, we’ve had so many thoughtful and compelling records from McGraw that when a new one comes along, it’s easy to take it for granted.  Standing in the shadow of “Live Like You Were Dying” is a hard place to shine.

So while “Better Than it Used to Be” is classic McGraw and a welcome relief to hear after “Felt Good on My Lips”, it’s not quite in the league of his very best songs in the same vein, like “One of These Days” and “My Next Thirty Years.”

But I do have to publicly thank him for the clean, tasteful, and decidedly country production.  Any record that doesn’t hurt my ears these days is greatly appreciated.

Written by Ashley Gorey and Brian Simpson

Grade: B+

Listen:  Better Than I Used to Be

Be Sociable, Share!

10 Comments

Filed under Single Reviews

10 Responses to Single Review: Tim McGraw, “Better Than I Used to Be”

  1. I agree entirely. It doesn’t out-do the best reflective moments of McGraw’s career, but it’s easily one of his best singles of the past few years. And it certainly is a relief to hear a record that’s easy on the ears!

  2. SweetcheeksNo Gravatar

    I thought “Felt Good On My Lips” was a great, fun song and much better than prior stuff like “Southern Voice.”

    I think Tim has really improved though since the days of “Indian Outlaw” and “Refried Dreams.” Those songs sound so corny, and quite frankly, so country, that they are hard to listen to. I appreciate the more mainstream and more sophisticated McGraw that emerged in the 2000s rather than the early McGraw.

  3. KeithNo Gravatar

    I think that McGraw’s version is just okay. I’d say that Sammy Kershaw’s version of the song is much better:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UPwAKwwu1m0

    Unfortunately, Kershaw doesn’t still have the radio presence that McGraw does.

  4. I agree that Kershaw’s version is superior, though McGraw’s is solid in its own right. It is a shame that Kershaw released the song at a point in his career at which he no longer had the commercial clout to make it a hit.

  5. DevinNo Gravatar

    I like the song a good bit. I just have a hard time supporting it under the circumstances it was released. It just seems wrong that Curb would stand to profit from a song like this when they’re likely responsible for a good bit of the lesser music we’ve gotten from McGraw in recent years.

  6. SweetcheeksNo Gravatar

    I believe McGraw has stated that he will be releasing his own single shortly. It will be interesting to see what happens if two McGraw singles are competing on the charts at the same time.

  7. RowdyRedNo Gravatar

    Thank you, Keith and Ben, for acknowledging songwriter Sammy Kershaw’s own beautiful rendition of this song. As much as Tim’s is pretty faithful, Sammy’s version is even more emotionally raw and real. I absolutely love it, and kind of protectively dismissed Tim’s on first hearing. Still, I must admit it’s faithfully presented and very likely to move folks to love it.

    I agree with you Ben, about radio access. Heck,last year when Sammy’s came out, I only heard it here in Louisiana on the Lafayette stations, and not once on the Lake Charles ones. Now that’s a regional market, and not in a good way. :(.

    I know Sammy will get some nice coin for this surefire hit (but I still wish he’d had that success with it himself). At any rate, I’ll give Tim high points for for excellent taste and a very good job.

  8. RowdyRedNo Gravatar

    Forgot to add, many thanks Keith, for posting the link to Sammy’s version. Now you can ALL wonder why radio didn’t bit on this one!

    (No, I’m not still bitter!)

  9. JoshNo Gravatar

    Rowdy – Kershaw didn’t write this song, so he won’t be making any money off of McGraw’s version. However, it’s such a heartfelt performance that it seems like he did.

  10. RowdyRedNo Gravatar

    Huh. Thanks a lot, google! Some ambiguous wording in some of those hits I got…I wuz confused!

    (I looked again and you’re right. You’re also right about Sammy’s performance, which is why I believed it was “his baby” in the first place.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This site is using OpenAvatar based on