“Who’s Your Daddy?”
Toby Keith
Written by Toby Keith
Radio & Records
#1 (1 week)
December 13, 2002
Billboard
#1 (1 week)
December 21, 2002
I dismissed this record 23 years ago and never looked back.
So imagine my surprise when I heard “Who’s Your Daddy?” with fresh ears and picked up on the fact that Keith is the side piece, not the woman he’s singing to.
This guy is in the same boat as Darryl Worley was on “When You Need My Love,” but he’s got money in his pocket and he’s quite happy to play the role of the big spender and the one night stand.
He does so with the unbridled enthusiasm of a second stringer being called off of the bench. He doesn’t have any interest in starting in each game. He’ll hang around, enjoy the single life, and have some fun when he gets the tap on the shoulder every once in a while.
His performance is brilliant in that context. Yes, this would be a lascivious mess with a different power balance.
That speaks to one of the underappreciated elements of Keith’s music. He had swagger, for sure, but he also made country music for consenting adults that had left the heartsick swoon of adolescence behind a long time ago.
I can only go so far with a song built around the line, “Who’s your daddy.” But I’ll go far enough to say this is a much more entertaining record than I gave it credit for the first time around, and it has far more in common with the best of Twitty and Strait than it does with any of the bro country that came in its wake.
Toby Keith was so damn good, especially when he wasn’t trying too hard.
“Who’s Your Daddy?” gets a B+.
Every No. 1 Single of the 2000s
Previous: Rascal Flatts, “These Days” |
Next: George Strait, “She’ll Leave You With a Smile”
I didn’t like this when it came out but like so much of his material, I have grown to really appreciate his talent. So clever compared to the others of this era. “A-“
It was easy to dismiss a song with as lecherous and provocative of a title as “Who’s Your Daddy?” and just dismiss it as “the new Toby” flapping his feathers like a peacock. But even 20+ years ago, I listened closely enough to pick up on the fact that the narrator was the side piece and not the college girl. It was a clever framing for a more PG-13-rated version of “When You Need My Love” or an updated Conway-style blusher, particularly since the narrator seems to be absolutely thrilled with himself for being able to pull it off. And as was so often the case with Toby Keith songs, the video and its surprise ending elevated its legacy.
Still, there are a couple of things that continue to not work for me here. First and foremost, the title is so full of innuendo that it cheapens the narrative and muddles the message into a hip-hop braggadocio, rendering it much less effective at every level than “When You Need My Love”. Second, I just never got into the song’s rhythm and found the sonic rewards marginal. As much as I heard this played on radio in 2002 and 2003, I don’t ever recall having the chorus stuck in my head. I could well be alone on that, but either way the song just never stuck with me in a way that quite a few of Toby’s uptempo numbers did. It was ultimately a road worth traveling for Toby creatively at this stage of his career, but I just didn’t connect with it or consider it worthy of going to #1.
Grade: C+
I think this one has the right level of swagger to not be overbearing or sexist. It’s also only one verse, which helps to keep the joke from dragging on too long. And I dig the groove. I think this one also got a B+ from me.
For those put off by the title, it could be worse. He could’ve titled this song “Whassup?” or “Booyah”.
Swagger can’t be fabricated. I can think of so many artists (ahem, like 99% of the bro country suspects) that try and fake it to horrible results. While he sometimes pushed it a little too far, Toby Keith had the swagger, and I think he walks the line nicely here. I’m glad to see others coming around to it, because I always thought the POV brought a unique element to it and kept it from being too demeaning. Not a top favorite of Toby’s, but one I still enjoy.
Swagger, a sense of humour, a surprising amount of sensitivity, and smarts defined Keith’s output as much as anything, assuming, of course, you actually listened to his music. More judgemental snap decisions and political statements were made about Toby Keith than any artist from this era, based upon nothing more than song titles.
Keith admittedly actively provided all the fuel, hot air, and heat to keep the fires of those conversations burning hot and tall. Toby Keith did not nurture neutrality.
Despite his aggressive arrogance, provocative persona, and imposing physical stature, Keith was quietly perhaps the best vocalist and songwriter of his generation.
He was an albums artist and shockingly consistent.
Keith is having a blast with the freedom to record singles like this and is completely within his creative element.
This feature will flatter Keith.
“Who’s Your Daddy?” Is a blast.