Every No. 1 Single of the 2000s: Tim McGraw, “Back When”

“Back When”

Tim McGraw

 Written by Stan Lynch, Stephony Smith, and Jeff Stevens

Radio & Records

#1 (1 week)

December 10, 2004

Billboard

#1 (1 week)

December 18, 2004

Tim McGraw is satirizing nostalgia while also fully indulging in it on “Back When,” a song that keeps its tongue firmly in cheek as it plays with homophones and waxes poetic about peanuts in a Dr. Pepper can and fried bologna sandwiches.

My dad loved fried bologna sandwiches and loved that line completely unironically, which still makes me smile.

That being said, this song is wafer thin, funny as it is. I love the rich details and deliberate contrasts of the verses, but the chorus is basically an excuse to use naughty words that sound like other words, and feign innocence and plausible deniability as you slip them into heavy rotation on country radio. It’s a trend that will continue from here, starting with the very next number one single in this series.

“Back When” was also an indication that the McGraw radio hit machine had suddenly shifted into a lower gear. He’ll only spend a single week more at number one for the rest of this decade, after a ten year stretch of multiple week number one singles that made him the most dominant radio artist of that time.

I miss back when this guy could sneak a Rodney Crowell ballad onto the radio and take it to the top for several weeks.

“Back When” gets a B.

Every No. 1 Single of the 2000s

Previous: Gary Allan, “Nothing On But the Radio” |

Next: Blake Shelton, “Some Beach”

YouTube player

Open in Spotify

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*