Album Review Roundup: Vol. 2, No. 3

Eric Bibb leads the week.

 

Eric Bibb

One Mississippi

As ever, what makes Bibb a genre titan is how he pairs the wisdom and POV of a forward-thinking folkie with a generational mastery of traditional blues conventions. This collection of narratives is among the most empathetic, deeply human of his storied career. Essential.

 

Melissa Carper & Theo Lawrence

Havin’ a Talk

Indeed, the vibe is conversational and casual in all the best ways, and it’s as charming as their solo efforts always are. It’s not quite as essential as their solo records, but that’s perhaps too high a bar to set for a purely fun side project like this.

 

Claudia Hoyser

Before the Dawn

To her credit, she’s spent the five years since her debut album building a robust brand and social media following, though both outstrip and oversell the quality of her just solid enough songwriting and modest vocal ability. It’s never more or less than adequate Music Row fare.

 

Jake Scott

Same Room

At some point, we’ll reach critical mass for this exact type of formless contemporary folk, but not yet, alas. Like Noah Kahan, Scott fares far better when he bothers to craft a pop hook than when he goes for Zach Bryan’s mope. In either case, these returns diminish.

Natalie Del Carmen

Pastures

Her debut announced one of Gen Z’s finest singer-songwriters, and this second outing finds NDC leveling up in a major way. These songs perfectly capture that mid-20s pressure to figure out the exact kind of adult you aspire to be on your best days.

She’s also figured out that it’s both the people and the places around her that will get her to where she wants to be, even if she’s not in much of a hurry.

Beyond the incisive songwriting, the heft of her singing impresses, as does her use of fiddle and steel as anchors, not authenticity props.

 

Catherine Britt

The Hardest Thing

Both for the superior quality of her writing and singing and for its concept– a long narrative arc about the phases of a doomed relationship– this set favorably recalls Allison Moorer’s landmark The Hardest Part from a generation back. Britt’s finest work to date.

Langhorne Slim

The Dreamin’ Kind

He’s an artist of many strengths, but the way this album careens from one aesthetic to another– he sounds like Slobberbone on one track, then vintage Cat Stevens on the next– does not play to them. Sure, those individual tracks are fine, but it’s a mess of an album.

6 Comments

  1. I haven’t seen anyone talk about them yet so I’m really curious, what do you (and anyone else) think of the four new songs on the deluxe edition of Trisha Yearwood’s The Mirror?

    • I made the decision in 2025 not to do reviews of “deluxe” album reissues, so I’m glad you asked about this!

      I actually really liked the new songs, though there were some issues with the meter of the lyrics on “Country Music Herstory” that I found super distracting both on their own merit and because that wasn’t something that was an issue on any of the other songs on the album proper. In terms of the overall thematic heft and the sequencing of The Mirror, I will say that I can see why these songs didn’t make the cut for the original version of the album.

      • I’m so glad you’re happy I asked! “Country Music Herstory” is my least favorite of the new tracks. I love “Different Kinda Hard” even if the lyrics are somewhat cliché. “Undone” is stunning. A career highlight. I love that she’s continuing to push herself this much 35 years into her career.

        I’ve grown so accustomed to Taylor Swift’s “data dumps” in recent years, (her words, although she was only referring to TTPD) that I wanted as much from this TY album as possible. I’m so happy we ended up with 20 tracks. Although these songs could’ve been the beginning of a sequel/sister/companion album. I know she wrote songs with Ashley McBryde and The Love Junkies we’ve yet to or may never hear.

  2. Thanks for the Catherine Britt tip! I didn’t know she had released a new album. I’m looking forward to listening to the entire album, but I like what I’ve heard so far.

    • I love the range of styles she incorporates over the course of the album. Some pure honky-tonk to go alongside some particularly well-done modern radio country. It’s a terrific album!

Leave a Reply to Peter Saros Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.


*