If this year’s singles list leaves you with a familiar feeling, it’s not your imagination. For the first time in Country Universe history, an artist has topped the year end list for two years in a row, and there are plenty of repeat appearances from CU favorites. But there are some fresh faces too, including some promising new singer-songwriters and inspired collaborations from artists we already liked an awful lot by themselves.
As always, share your thoughts and personal favorites in the comments!
“Hangin’ Up My Heart”
Emmylou Harris & Rodney Crowell
Individual rankings: #3 – Leeann; #20 – Kevin
What a way for Emmylou and Rodney to kick off their much anticipated duet project! The bouncy tune shows the power duo in fine form both in voice and spunk and signals what will turn out to be one of the finest albums of the year. – Leeann Ward
“It Ain’t the Whiskey”
Individual rankings: #10 – Dan; #13 – Jonathan; #18 – Kevin
The most Allan has sounded like his old self in seven years. You can’t blame him for dialing back his intensity after the dark, heartbreaking Tough All Over, but it’s a real treat to hear him snarl out a great country weeper again.- Dan Milliken
“Railroad of Sin”
Individual rankings: #5 – Jonathan; #8 – Sam
It’s hard to pick out a highlight from Simpson’s High Top Mountain, but this song would have to be in the running. Though just a shade over two minutes in length, “Railroad” roars, rumbles and packs in more energy and attitude than whole albums from Blake Shelton or Luke Bryan. For those starving for pure, unadulterated country music, Simpson’s debut album was one of the great joys of 2013. – Sam Gazdziak
Kelly Willis and Bruce Robison
Individual rankings: #9 – Jonathan; #18 – Ben; #19 – Sam; #20 – Tara
Few singers are as adept as Kelly Willis at making their misery sound downright joyful. Even when she’s telling her ex that a lifetime of crying might suffice to get over him, Willis sounds like she’s determined to enjoy, either out of spite or pure masochism, each and every one of the tears she has in her future. – Jonathan Keefe
Individual rankings: #3 – Dan; #5 – Kevin
“You ain’t worth the spit in my mouth when I scream out your name.” McKenna minces no words whatsoever as her steady, rumbling rage builds into a righteous evisceration of a selfish lover. Masterfully chosen details convey the full depth of the heartbreak in a few simple lines. Staggering. – Dan Milliken
“Bible on the Dash”
Corb Lund featuring Hayes Carll
Individual rankings: #5 – Jonathan; #8 – Sam
Lund and Carll share a similar twisted sense of humor, so this song about using a Bible to sweet-talk their way through police stops is right up their alleys. The video, featuring Carll as a Texas state trooper and Lund as a Mountie, is worth seeking out as well. – Sam Gazdziak
“Long Time Gone”
Billie Joe + Norah
Individual rankings: #2 – Leann; #17 – Tara; #19 – Kevin
The tight vocals of Norah Jones and Green Day’s Billie Joe Armstrong are both surprising and stunning. From their collaborative project that covers the entire Everly Brother’s Songs Our Daddy Taught Us album, Jones and Armstrong brilliantly recreate the magic of the Brothers’ familial harmonies without actually being family themselves on the album’s first single, “Long Time Gone.” The song is bright and hard core country, not to mention it can be replayed a million times over without feeling stale. – Leeann Ward
“Could it Be”
Individual rankings: #10 – Tara, Jonathan; #12 – Sam; #14 – Dan
A throwback to the uncomplicated pop-country sound of the ‘90s –part Vince Gill, part Clay Walker, part Diamond Rio– that still sounds undeniably current, thanks to one of the freshest opening hooks in recent memory. – Tara Seetharam
“If I Loved You”
Delta Rae featuring Lindsey Buckingham
Individual rankings: #3 – Jonathan; #5 – Tara; #19 – Dan
Delta Rae can, at times, skew a little too far into “show choir” territory, but “If I Loved You” isn’t one of those times. Their intricate harmonies, dramatic dynamic shifts, and outsized vocal performances are entirely in service to a song about how deeply it can hurt when, “It isn’t you, it’s me,” is the truth and not just a cop-out. – Jonathan Keefe
“All Kinds of Kinds”
Individual rankings: #2 – Sam; #11 – Leeann, Tara; #12 – Dan
This oddity is something that could only have come from the pen of Don Henry, along with co-writer Phillip Coleman. While the women in country music are more likely to be singing about married circus performers and cross-dressing politicians, Lambert is the best-suited to sing about a rebellious child determined to make her own way in life. – Sam Gazdziak
“Blue Ridge Mountain Song”
Individual rankings: #8 – Kevin, Leeann, Ben; #9 – Tara
Something of a close cousin to his classic “Livin’ on Love”, the storyline of this young couple is so similar that it’s quite the sucker-punch when they don’t get their happily ever after. As the protagonist falls to his knees, begging God not to take his love away from him, Jackson lets that moment linger in our hearts and minds as the bluegrass band takes over for a short time. When he returns with the heart-wrenching image of our widowed hero sitting on the front porch all alone, with only memories to keep him company, it’s a hurt that returns with every listen, as unquenchable as grief itself. – Kevin Coyne
Individual rankings: #4 – Leeann; #6 – Tara; #13 – Kevin; #17 – Dan; #19 – Jonathan
“Drinkin” is far more than its simple title. While cleverly connecting the end to the beginning, the song explores the slippery slope of excessive drinking and its ravaging effects on a family. It starts with Williams pleading for understanding for why her mate is “drinking like the night is young” and ends with her own version of personal understanding as she realizes that she has been driven to go down that same distructive road. – Leeann Ward
“Gasoline and Matches”
LeAnn Rimes featuring Rob Thomas
Individual rankings: #1 – Leeann, Ben; #13 – Dan; #17 – Jonathan
Rimes’ astounding growth as a vocal interpreter is hardly limited to her ballads – on “Gasoline and Matches” she rocks out like never before, tearing into the deliriously catchy Buddy and Julie Miller song with an uninhibited spitfire (pun intended) of a performance. Rob Thomas proves an ideal match for Rimes’ energy and intensity, the two displaying an explosive chemistry that perfectly fits the song’s central metaphor. Finish it off with an aggressive, driving production, complete with a searing Jeff Beck guitar solo, and you have one of the most unabashedly addictive songs of 2013. – Ben Foster
Individual rankings: #4 – Sam; #5 – Dan; #6 – Kevin; #8 – Tara; #13 – Leeann
“What are You Listening To”
Individual rankings: #2 – Tara; #9 – Kevin, Dan; #12 – Leeann; #15 – Jonathan; #17 – Sam
Simply the most cathartic song about songs in years, layering blues and soul with the kind of crushing anguish only a master class vocal can convey. – Tara Seetharam
Individual rankings: #3 – Kevin; #5 – Leeann; #7 – Tara, Jonathan; #11 – Dan
LeAnn Rimes’ career of late has been all about her choices. “Borrowed” may touch upon the decisions she’s made in her private life, but what’s far more interesting about the single are the choices she makes in her nuanced vocal performance. The way she breaks her voice into the high note as she sings the word “borrowed” at the end of each chorus, how she drops into her lower register whenever she’s admitting her status as the proverbial Other Woman, and the clarity and resolve in her delivery of the line, “I don’t want to give you back”: They’re all choices of a truly masterful storyteller. – Jonathan Keefe
Individual rankings: #3 – Ben; #6 – Leeann; #7 – Sam; #8 – Dan; #13 – Tara; #15 – Kevin
The unintentionally anti-revenge song, “Stripes” is clever and funny. While she would like to commit a crime of passion as a consequence for her lover’s cheating ways, she decides against it because “there’s no crime of passion worth a crime of fashion.” But even when the silly punch line wears off, Clark’s endearing performance and the addictive rhythm section will prevent the song from descending into lame novelty status. – Leeann Ward
Little Big Town
Individual rankings: #1 – Tara, Jonathan; #2 – Ben; #4 – Dan; #16 – Sam; #18 – Leeann
Country music’s done well by love: It understands it, respects it and celebrates it without adornment. But few country songs have tapped into as exquisitely –as spiritually, even– as “Sober,” an arms-raised surrender that dares to mirror the intoxication of love. There’s not a hint of restraint in “Sober’s” fabric, no self-consciousness in its confessional chorus or lilting harmonies. Sweetest of all is the abandon in Kimberly Schlapman’s performance, so mesmerizing that you can’t help but feel a little mind-altered yourself. – Tara Seetharam
“Mama’s Broken Heart”
Individual rankings: #2 – Kevin, Dan; #3 – Sam; #4 – Tara, Ben; #15 – Leeann; #20 – Jonathan
Kacey Musgraves and Brandy Clark dominate the top five of this list as writers and performers, and “Mama’s Broken Heart” is a further reminder how compelling their writing is, even in the hands of other performers. Lambert’s manic energy and signature edge is often paired with over the top material, so it’s awesome to hear her tear into a relatively grounded breakup song. You know if she wrote this, she wouldn’t be just cutting her bangs with those rusty kitchen scissors. The more realistic approach taken here allows for some sly generational and feminist commentary, another signature of both Musgraves and Clark, and Lambert, too, when she’s at her best. – Kevin Coyne
“Follow Your Arrow”
Individual rankings: #1 – Dan, Sam; #3 – Tara; #4 – Kevin, Jonathan; #5 – Ben; #14 – Leeann
Surprised? You’re probably not surprised. Musgraves topped our singles list last year with the sharp “Merry Go ‘Round,” and if anything, “Follow Your Arrow” one-ups it, offering an uplifting antidote to the malaise that “Merry Go ‘Round” warns of: go forth and live happily, whatever the word may mean to you.
There’s a little more to it, of course. The song is historically huge in its warm embrace of sexual diversity and religious tolerance, and its commentary on body image issues isn’t far behind. It rides a plucky, acoustic groove that dares to believe modern country music can sound like John Prine. It looks at life the way life really is, complicated and controversial, and does so with concise phrasing and a working sense of humor—why, that sounds like a classic country song to me. – Dan Milliken
Country Universe’s Best of 2013:
I solidly disagree with your #1 selection. It probably wouldn’t make my Top Twenty, in all honesty, as much as I commend the shiny yet understated production and Musgraves’ sweet nuanced vocal performance. The lyrics just underwhelmed me more than most reviewers. I simply find “All Kinds of Kinds” a more effective single at hitting home the call for inclusiveness with its idiosyncratic yet warm character descriptions backed by a neo-traditional production. “Follow Your Arrow”, on the other hand, isn’t as impactful on a person level and veers a bit too heavily to tribalism on lines including the reflections on churchgoing.
Despite that considerable nitpick, however, I otherwise strongly agree with your selections. My #1 would be “Stripes”, followed closely by “Deadman’s Blues” by Matt Woods and “What Are You Listening To?” by Chris Stapleton.
Great list. “Follow Your Arrow” would also top my personal best of 2013 list Miranda Lambert also has my #2 favorite single of the year, but “All Kinds of Kinds” and not “Mama’s Broken Heart”. The latter just didn’t hold up as well after repeated listenings. Happy New Year!
I like the songs by Worsham, Stapleton and Brandy. I heard Brandy sing “Mama’s Broken Heart” and prefer hearing her take over Miranda’s.
As I commented on J. Pap’s blog, my only complaint about “All Kinds of Kinds” is that it should have been a 3 minute song but runs on to 4:27 with nothing meaningful or interesting in the last minute and a half.
Songs I would have had in the top 20 include Maggie Rose’s “Better”, “Joe Bachman’s “Soldier’s Memoir”, “Trouble Is as Trouble Does” by Striking Matches and Wade Bowen’s “Songs About Trucks”. How can you leave a song out of the top 40 that addresses one of the main problems in 2013 country music:
“So mister here’s my 20 bucks
Don’t play no songs about trucks”
Solid list. I’ll have to check out some of these.
My list is far more mainstream:
20. “Carolina”, Parmalee
19. “Doin’ It Right”, Rodney Atkins
18. “All Over The Road”, Easton Corbin
17. “Drink A Beer”, Luke Bryan
16. “What Are You Listening To?”, Chris Stapleton
15. “Sunny and 75”, Joe Nichols
14. “Bourbon In Kentucky”, Dierks Bentley
13. “Like Jesus Does”, Eric Church
12. “Bruises”, Train feat. Ashley Monroe
11. “Cheat On You”, Big & Rich
10. “Mama’s Broken Heart”, Miranda Lambert
09. “Hey Pretty Girl”, Kip Moore
08. “All Kinds Of Kinds”, Miranda Lambert
07. “I Drive Your Truck”, Lee Brice
06. “Don’t Let Me Be Lonely”, The Band Perry
05. “It Ain’t The Whiskey”, Gary Allan
04. “Mine Would Be You”, Blake Shelton
03. “Sober”, Little Big Town
02. “Follow Your Arrow”, Kacey Musgraves
01. “Dance Baby Dance”, Chris Cagle
I’m suprised “Hey Pretty Girl” and/or “I Drive Your Truck” didn’t make it.
…got a ton of work on my desk and what am i doin’ – i delve into my favourite end of year lists in the whole of country’s universe… and just love it. thoughtful choices and comments, as usual.
thanks and happy new year, folks.
So much to explore here. I love it. My list is decidedly more mainstream and I’ve divided it in two: best American and Canadian country songs. Please check them out! Thanks.
Great list. Not sure if they were released as singles, but “Cover Me Up” and “Elephant” on Isbell’s record are essential listens. I’d also throw in “Tin Star” from Lindi Ortega’s album as a must listen.
6 songs in your top 40 made the top 10 on radio. Only one song in your top 20 made the radio top 10. I guess those numbers were to be expected.
I’m glad to see Charlie Worsham get some attention, he’s really impressed me. I hope 2014 is his breakout year. I also have fingers crossed for Chris Stapleton. My top 40 also would’ve included Jamie Lynn Spears’ debut single, “How Could I Want More.” I had incredibly low expectations for her but I really liked that song. Here’s hoping country takes a big step forward in 2014!
Some songs from 2013 that deserved notice:
* Pistol Annies – Damn Thing
* Josh Pruno – 23rd Psalm
* Easton Corbin – Tulsa Texas
* Tim McGraw – Friend of a Friend
* Sheryl Crow – Homecoming Queen
* Tracy Lawrence – Cecil’s Place
* Gary Allan – You Without Me
* Jason Isbell – Live Oak
* Vince Gill and Paul Franklin – Nobody’s Fool
* Kacey Musgraves – My House
* Dustin Lynch – Hurricane
* Kenny Chesney and Willie Nelson – Coconut Tree
No particular order. Just thought these deserved more attention than they got this year.
I like the list for the most part, however, I would have went with “Life Ain’t Fair and the World is Mean” from Sturgill Simpsons album.
I love “Life Ain’t Fair and the World is Mean”!
Not a huge fan of “Follow your arrow”, but I htink the main reason is because just the whole vibe sounds like “Merry go Round” to me. The sound of the song seems s similar, but with different lyrics. If I had never heard the first one, then I would enjoy “Follow your arrow” more. That was my only complaint with Kacey’s album, a lot of it just seemed like the same to me.